My experience is not in government policy, law, or economics. I can’t pretend to be expert on any of these things or to know what from within the system would be most effective or most politically pragmatic.
What I know from activism is that there are contradictions at every turn in trying to get the system to do things differently, because the worlds of policy, law and economics all share the same rotten foundation. There are definitely things needed in the short-term to reduce the harm being done right now and stop people from dying. But fundamentally these emergency measures don’t transform how we are with the land and each other. Without that transformation I don’t know that we’ll ever get close to ending homelessness.
I am not inspired by any of the current options available for providing housing to people, whether by government or the private market. Neither recognize how material resources have accumulated through the exploitation of Indigenous, poor and working class peoples, and the need for a radical restructuring of resource distribution, power and control. Calling for more social housing reinforces settler state jurisdiction on stolen land, and can result in warehousing or coercive ‘supportive’ housing that robs people of their autonomy and dignity and institutionalizes people. Trying to amp up options for people in the private market reinforces housing as a commodity, legitimizes land theft, makes rich people richer, and gives land owners, property managers, and others in the housing industry significant power over other people’s lives and Indigenous peoples’ lands and resources. It’s all fucked.
I’ve written this to remind myself that there may be points of divergence in how we understand the housing crisis and what its roots are, and that’s not really about economic and political arguments for or against rent supplements/housing allowances, it’s about something deeper and bigger that is much more nebulous and way harder to articulate. If nothing else writing it out helps me think it through a bit more, and that is helpful, so thank you for that.