• About
  • Issue 8, Spring 2017
  • Past issues
  • Downtown East
  • Contact
  • Support Us
  • Events
  • Newsletter

Menu
  • About
  • Issue 8, Spring 2017
  • Past issues
  • Downtown East
  • Contact
  • Support Us
  • Events
  • Newsletter

The Housing Crisis and Anti-Asian Racism: By 何盈欣 Beverly Ho and 馮葉 Stephanie Fung

volc8no December 9, 2016     Chinese, Gentrification & displacement, Housing crisis & struggles, Newsletter posts, Racism & migrant justice, Social Movement strategies

harpers-white-canadaThis is an edited version of a talk delivered at “The Housing Crisis is Global: Anti-Imperialist Perspectives on the foreign investment myth” panel discussion organized by Alliance Against Displacement and Chinatown Action Group, November 22 2016.

Beverly Ho: Our talk tonight is focused on anti-Asian racism because it’s very obvious, especially in its recent heightened and overt form that it has taken, and in light of the recent election of Donald Trump as well as in light of how the housing crisis is occurring. To connect it to Chinatown, where I work with Chinese seniors, the foreign investment myth, just like the model minority myth, may seem like they’re not that harmful, but they both profoundly and very negatively affect Chinese residents.

ccgGentrification and displacement in Chinatown

Specifically, in the Chinatown neighbourhood there has been unprecedented development and displacement, especially of low-income residents. Many shops serving the low income Chinese community have closed down, and I’m sure if you’ve been to Chinatown you have seen the drastic changes that are occurring.

Last week, the Chinatown Concern Group spoke up against the discriminatory policies and undemocratic practices of the City of Vancouver. Most of our members are working class and female Chinese seniors who only speak Chinese. Specifically, Chinatown Concern Group addressed two open houses that the City held last month, regarding the Chinatown Economic Revitalization Action Plan. Like a lot of open houses and consultations that the City of Vancouver does, there was very inadequate translation and interpretation provided. They also used vague and exclusive planning terms and vocabulary that was hard to understand. And there was tremendously low turnout: only 80 people showed up to the two open houses that were meant for all of Chinatown. This is because many of our members who we have spoken to said they didn’t receive any notices about these open houses, even though many of them wanted to attend. They were purposely excluded.

This is concerning for us because they are the most vulnerable and at risk. Chinese seniors also have the biggest stake in Chinatown because it’s their home and because it’s a very culturally specific place that they need.

The City has heard a lot of opposition to the Historic Area Heights Review, which was passed in 2011 and attracted a lot of developers to the area. Though they heard a lot of dissenting voices, they have not addressed these voices and their concerns in the policy review. There will be only 20% affordable housing; they said “affordable” but this could mean $800/month or more for rent. It won’t be at pension or welfare rate.

So the press conference that Chinatown Concern Group held in response to this centred marginalized voices and put a new narrative into mainstream media. It emphasized the way vulnerable communities have not been a part of the policy process. It questioned how policy consultation processes are structured when the most affected are not included.

white-immigration-oriental-exclusionRacism roots the foreign investment myth and the displacement of our communities

The foreign investment myth is rooted in racism, and racism plays out in very real and violent ways against low-income Chinese seniors in the neighbourhood. Many non-Chinese residents, because of the media or internalized racism, hold prejudiced and harmful assumptions about Chinese people. A lot of Chinese people are assaulted on the streets and in food line-ups, and many don’t feel safe in their own homes and neighbourhoods.

Racism divides poor people, and not just the Chinese community. Poor people are disproportionately affected by racism. The particular kind of anti-Chinese racism that seniors we work with experience, and the way that Chinese people are “foreignized,” isn’t new and it hasn’t ended. Many people think that we’re post-racial, and that’s not true.

Historically, the government sanctioned racist policies like the Chinese Head Tax and the Exclusion Act. Today, policies in Chinatown encourage market development and gentrification. Gentrification is often seen as “natural” or as progress, something necessary to clean up a city. In reality, gentrification is displacement and it’s putting people’s lives at risk. It has a huge impact on people’s mental and physical health.

In the City’s supposed consultation process with residents, Chinatown Concern Group was also concerned about the choice of language used by the City. For example, the words “consultation” or “open house” or “revitalization” should be words with positive connotations, but the City has twisted these words and used them as covers for their displacement policies. “Revitalization” is also an inaccurate term; Chinatown is not dead.

In Chinatown, the housing crisis that we see is not caused by foreign investment – it’s caused by local developers. It is led by WestBank Corporations, Beedie Living, Bosa Properites, and the Prospero Group. These B.C.-based developers are the real groups contributing to the housing crisis and increasing property prices.

Now, we see that the new manifestation of racism, particularly anti-Asian or anti-Chinese racism, is the foreign investment narrative. Capitalism is also founded in racism, displacement, and in taking advantage of the working class. A lot of white settlers see the influx of affluent people of colour and it fuels their xenophobia and resentment. This is because capitalism is supposed to primarily benefit white settlers.

Racism affects people of all classes but it affects poor people the most. In terms of displacement and gentrification as well, these forces affect poor people the most. Growing up as a person of colour and as a Chinese person, somehow our communities believed that we can escape racism or prejudice by working hard and moving up social classes, which is a lot like the American dream. We are tricked into thinking that capitalism is democratic or fair and that we all start at the same starting point. But I’ve seen that money doesn’t change the colour of your skin.

It’s important that we continue fighting colonialism and gentrification as well, because fighting gentrification is also fighting racism especially in the context of Chinatown. Just like colonialism, gentrification is justified by the idea of progress and development, which are misleading terms that mask the forces of colonialism and gentrification.

Stephanie Fung: Foreign investment has happened in the past in other parts of the world, which we can trace back to imperial conquests of Europeans and later North Americans. And it continues to happen today and not just in Vancouver; it’s happening in cities in Asia such as Hong Kong, Singapore, Beijing, and Shang Hai. These cities are going through a global housing crisis and they’re also addressing it in different ways. Globalization has been happening for a while and in places across the world.

men-of-canadaIntersections of racism, capitalism, and settler colonialism

The main question I’m interested in tonight is how do racism, capitalism, and settler colonialism inform each other in the context of Vancouver’s current housing crisis and foreign investment today.

The first part I want to talk about is the history of anti-Chinese racism in Vancouver within a settler colonial context. As Beverly touched upon, Chinese migrants in Vancouver have long been subjected to racism, including the race riots of 1907; the Head Tax of 1885, the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1923. What is interesting to me is how these histories have influenced present day experiences of Chinese people as associated with money and with capital. We can see how racism has been used as a tool by white settlers to reinforce this position of Asian migrants as labourers and Asians as part of this settler colonial context, contributing to the displacement and colonization of Indigenous peoples.

I look to Iyko Day’s claim that Asians have been racialized through capitalist settler colonial projects. I think it’s important to recognize this because we can understand how these colonial histories have shaped present day racist view of Asians. This is connected to a destructive form of capitalism, and it has influenced the narratives we have today about Chinese immigrants taking over the housing market. These narratives have antagonized Asians and have caused divisions across marginalized communities. The association of Asians with negative capitalism has allowed white settlers to gloss over and erase their complicity with capitalist exploitation from collective memory and history.

The narrative of the foreign investment is indeed rooted in racism and colonialism. Foreign buyer influence has shaped the current housing crisis, but foreign investment is just one of many reasons for this crisis. Moreover, data indicates that foreign investment is small; actually the majority of foreign investors in B.C. are Europeans and Americans who account for 70% combined. Only 22% of foreign investment comes from Asian investors. And this is from the BC Assessment Authority, the 2010 Property Statistics.

savechinatownWhat can be done?

One of the biggest questions that I have is what can be done, and how do we relate the displacement that is occurring in Chinatown to wider forms of displacement that affect many different people? I think there are two ways that we can start to address these issues and expand housing security.

First, I think we have to dismantle settler colonial structures. It’s important to understand that decolonization is applicable across all communities and if we are going to strategize and talk about how to solve the housing crisis, we have to strategize alongside Indigenous communities and understand their movements for sovereignty and self-determination.

Secondly, more inter- and intra-community dialogues need to happen that involve the most vulnerable. Open houses aren’t enough and they are imperfect vehicles for housing justice. By intercommunity, this means we must recognize that the Chinese community in Chinatwon is not homogenous. There are diverse players, leaders, and groups within this community with different class interests and views of what Chinatown should look like. Intercommunity conversations across generations that involved low-income working class seniors’ voices especially is crucial. In other words, the Chinatown Action Group is interested in working with those in the Chinese community who are invested in fighting for those who are most marginalized and oppressed.

By intracommunity, I mean that conversations need to happen across communities. The issues of gentrification and displacement happening in Chinatown and in the Downtown Eastside are connected to what is happening in many different neighbourhoods across Vancouver, in Burnaby and the Metrotown neighbourhood, near Joyce Skytrain Station, and in the Renfrew-Collingwood neighbourhood. In these conversations that we’re having, we need to address the root causes of poverty, displacement, and gentrification. More than anything else, we need to have a shared analysis of these structures of power and processes of settler colonialism, imperialism, and global capitalism.

Ultimately, we need to organize for social justice to address the structural issues in society. It is about building a community that wants to get to the root of social problems, and it is about having conversations with people on the ground and trying to move them to our side of justice. So if we want to talk about concrete actions, this could mean working with Chinatown Action Group, participating in discussion groups, and listening to Chinese seniors and building relationships with them. We must speak about displacement within our own communities.

What we need to focus on is building stronger cross-community alliances across the city and building a deeper collective analysis of what is happening in order to take action for housing justice and ensure that everyone has access to safe and affordable housing.

何盈欣 Beverly Ho is a Chinese settler artist and organizer born and raised on the west coast with ancestral origins  in 三水 (Samshui),廣東 (Kwangtung) and 常州 (Ch’ang Chou), 江蘇 (Kiangsu). She is grateful to be working with and constantly learning from several groups in the neighborhood, including Chinatown Action Group, the Alliance Against Displacement, Chinatown Concern Group, and Youth for Chinese Seniors.

馮葉 Stephanie Fung traces her family’s migratory routes from 廣東 Guangdong, where her grandparents lived until they fled to 香港 Hong Kong during the Japanese occupation of China in World War 2. Her parents later migrated to Turtle Island in the late 1980s. Stephanie lives, works, and creates as a visitor on the unceded territories of the sḵwx̱wú7mesh, sel̓íl̓witulh, and xʷməθkʷəy̓əm nations, where she supports the struggles of marginalized communities in Chinatown with the Chinatown Action Group. She also works for the UBC Asian Canadian and Asian Migration Studies Program.

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Google+ (Opens in new window)

 Previous Post

Canada is not our only enemy – An anti-colonial perspective on foreign investment in British Columbia: By Natalie Knight

― December 9, 2016

Next Post 

December 4 – December 10, 2016 Volcano Newsletter

― December 9, 2016

Related Articles

Either version of the NDP’s proposed Tenancy Act reforms will continue the mass eviction of Metro Vancouver: By Ivan Drury
No Pill For This Ill: The Downtown Eastside community launches a report and vision for mental health: By the editors
City of Victoria Pledges Millions More to Cops not Homes: By Dani Cooper
“There’s definitely an anti-Indigenous energy in the police here” – Indigenous land defenders targeted by police violence in the Kinder Morgan pipeline fight: By J. H. Feicken
The Volcano launches a podcast! Podcast #1 – Critiques of the Foreign Investment Myth: By listen chen (陳聽春), Isabel Krupp, Ivan Drury
Our Language – Transmisogyny / Transantagonism: By Laura Paul
Pacific Rim Anti-Chinese Nativism and the Safeguarding of the Liberal World Order: By listen chen (陳聽春)
Progressive Austerity, Canadian Nationalism & the B.C. NDP’s 2018 Housing Plan: By Isabel Krupp
Mobilizing the Frontline of the Eviction Crisis – Burnaby Metrotown’s We Won’t Go Campaign: By Zoe Luba
Back to the War on Drugs – Canada’s Public Health/Public Safety response to the Fentanyl Overdose Crisis: By Ashley Mollison
Liberation, Decolonization, Gacaca – Reflecting on the Rwandan Genocide, 24 Years Later: By Lama Mugabo
Imperialism, capitalism, and the revolutionary potential of urban Indigenous land relationships: By Natalie Knight (Yurok/Navajo)
One, two, many tent cities – Nanaimo homeless fightback moves from protest towards resistance: By Ivan Drury
Defend tent city! Our survival is our togetherness in the street: Anita Place Tent City statement in solidarity with Nanaimo tent city fighters
“A white man’s freedom is more important than an Indigenous person’s life” – Indigenous responses to the Boushie & Fontaine murders: By Natalie Knight (Yurok/Navajo), Sadie Morris (Nuu-chah-nulth/Irish) and Pauline Morris (Nuu-chah-nulth/Gitxsan/Irish)
The Volcano Reappears! By The Volcano Editors: Natalie Knight, Listen Chen, JJ Riach, Ivan Drury, Harold Lavender, Shannon Bundock
Low-income residents and community groups turned out in force to oppose 105 Keefer condo project, pressure Vancouver City Council to defer decision: By Chinatown Concern Group & Chinatown Action Group
We would rather have a vacant lot than another condo development: By Jannie Leung 梁泳詩, Chinatown Action Group 華埠行動小組
人民優先於利潤!公益房屋優先於華廈!:奇化街105 地段 梁泳詩, 華埠行動小組
Building confidence and power in low-income elder women’s Chinatown: By Beverly Ho
Beedie’s 105 Keefer condo tower threatens the existence of Chinatown’s most vulnerable residents: By Celine Chuang
Culture is a collective product of people and relationships, not a commodity: By Yuly Chan
Don’t condemn Chinatown to the same fate suffered by Vancouver’s Pauerugai: By Angela Kruger
Do not tell us the City cares about people more than profits – show us! By Lenée Son
More unaffordable housing and unaffordable retailers and unaffordable restaurants is going to save Chinatown? I’m not buying it: By Mark Lee | 陳德聰
Ten Year and Anita Place Tent Cities: Security for the homeless, sites of struggle for us all: By the Editors
Ten Year Tent City beats Vancouver in Court! By Maria Wallstam
Saving lives, a sense of pride, and trans women’s safety at 10 Year Tent City: Affidavits from the defendants against the City of Vancouver’s failed injunction attempt
Anita Place tent city forging a new anti-poverty politics in Maple Ridge: By Ivan Drury
Rally calls for Maple Ridge to lift eachother up and reject bullying, anti-homeless hate, and vigilante violence: Speeches from Anita Place defense rally
Four Principles for a Tent Cities Movement: Drafted at Super InTent City Victoria, February 2016
Founding Declaration of Anita Place Tent City, Maple Ridge 2017
Homelessness, poverty, and the police state: Anti-election week of action exposes the ugly reality of BC’s future: By the Editors
BC’s real housing crisis revealed in Maple Ridge: Standing in solidarity with residents of Anita Place Tent City: By Lama Mugabo
Open letter to John Horgan: Cut Anne Kang and stand with the People of Metrotown By Astrid Castaneda, Zoe Luba, Sadie Morris, Sara Sagaii
Community Spotlight – Jean Swanson, a life against poverty: By Sarah Sheridan
Just Imagine! Rest, music, and the richness of life in the Downtown Eastside community: By Priscillia Mays Tait
Women supporting Women in the Downtown Eastside: By Dave Diewert
It’s time to be moved to action against poverty: By Trish Garner
Why we have homelessness: By Jean Swanson
Editorial: BC Liberal mould has infected the walls of the house and only the people can get it out
The BC Liberal new-normal – A brief history of how we got in this mess: By Jean Swanson and Ivan Drury
From serving workers to serving the NDP – Electoral pragmatism and the end of a fightin’ democratic unionism: An interview with BCTF activist Tina Anderson by Ivan Drury
After the Fightback – Remobilizing labour and anti-capitalist resistance in the BC Liberal era: By Ivan Drury
The NDP won’t save renters: By Harold Lavender and Sarah Sheridan
Kwantlen Nation digs in against the Kinder Morgan pipeline expansion: By PJ Lilley
Worldviews – Urban Indigenous frontlines, experience, and survival: By Sadie Morris, West Coast Raindrop
City of Duncan uses courts to displace tent city sending homelessness back into hiding: By Ashley Mollison
Simon Fraser University kills its Indigenous education program, continuing its legacy of mismanaging Indigenous education funding: By Natalie Knight
Continuing the fight for Homes Not Jails: By Super InTent City Council
Demovicted tenants need City defence, not assistance: Metrotown demoviction delegation shut out of Burnaby policy meeting: By Zoe Luba
Shelter residents: ‘Closing shelters is a human rights violation’: By Carnegie Community Action Project
A post-viaduct Hogan’s Alley will redress racist history or it will continue displacement: By Alliance Against Displacement
Inaction about Soldiers of Odin a Threat in Vancouver: By Imtiaz Popat
A disingenuous thank you: BC Liberals pose over the bodies of the thousand lost to overdoses – By Anonymous
Out of Control: SRO hotel survey finds that market real estate development and low-welfare rates are to blame for record homelessness in the Downtown Eastside – By Carnegie Community Action Project
Stop Displacement! Save Whale Wall! Fighting gentrification-by-playground in Victoria – By Leilani Rodriguez
Federal government’s message to homeless people: get a good tarp and sleeping bag and prepare to die young – By Maria Wallstam
NOTE: Women’s library article held for discussion
Copper skin: By West Coast Raindrop – Sadie Morris
Indigenous land defenders call for the creation of the Sacred Fire Network: By Natalie Knight
BC anti-election column: BC Liberals and NDP both promise a renewed war on street-level drug dealers: By Ashley Mollison
Electromagnetic Print Emits a Pulse – New Vancouver book publisher focuses on Indigenous and radical texts: By Joseph Jones
Mayor’s office sit-in nets Demovictions movement its first partial victory against the City of Burnaby: By Zoe Luba
Creating Temp Tenants – Burnaby’s demoviction tenant assistance policy abandons the most vulnerable and subsidizes condo developers: By Ivan Drury
“We are too poor to afford anything” – new report uncovers the power of retail shops in the gentrification of Chinatown and the Downtown Eastside: By Leneé Son, Carnegie Community Action Project Coordinator
Open letter to the City of Victoria Mayor & Council and Island Health: By No Cops on Outreach Victoria, Lekwungen Territories
Under an unjust state, break unjust laws – A call to revisit our strategies and take different actions: By the Editors
Go ahead displace me, you’re going to have to kill me to get me to stop fighting: By Daniel Bernard Phillip Isadore (Driftpile Cree)
The only way to survive is to break the law – Vancouver’s DTES Economic Development Plan continues the criminalization of the poor: By Maria Wallstam
Our veins run with water, not oil – fighting for our lives against capitalism and colonialism across Turtle Island: By Seb Bonet
Hell No We Won’t Go – Demovictions, the end of social democracy, and the rise of an alternative: By Ivan Drury
The (Un)realities of Reconciliation: By Herb Varley
Homelessness is not a crime – Resistance to the criminalization of homeless survival in the everyday Downtown Eastside: By Maria Wallstam
“It’s gotten creepy down here now” – Police Occupy the Strip in Surrey: By Dave Diewert
The class anxiety of Ridgeilantes – Uncovering the shared roots of homelessness and anti-homeless hate in Maple Ridge: By Ivan Drury
Rebuilding Hogan’s Alley through the Black community’s struggle for historical justice: By Lama Mugabo
Community media and the fight against gentrification in Medellin, Colombia: By Jhony Alexánder Díaz Castañeda – Corporación Mi Comuna, Medellin
Will fixed term leases erase 40 years of tenant organizing in the Downtown Eastside? By Jean Swanson
Provincial housing money a drop in the bucket: By Jean Swanson 
Cut the CRAP! Chinatown Concern Group fights Vancouver’s rezoning and gentrification of Chinatown: By Beverly Ho, Chinatown Concern Group
We can’t do it alone – support the upcoming issue of The Volcano newspaper! By the Editors
Community Policing and the health and overdose prevention dimensions of Vancouver’s war on drugs: By the Editors with a statement by Alliance Against Displacement
“The USA is not a safe country!” To fight Trump racism from north of the border we need to focus on distinctly Canadian racism: By the Editors
BC Liberal self-celebrated Overdose Prevention Strategy doesn’t amount to much in practice: By Ivan Drury
Metrotown Downtown Plan versus the Metrotown People’s Plan: By Letizia Waddington
Keep Warm, Burn Out the Warming Shelters: By Maria Wallstam
When we see racists getting organized, that’s a symptom – Anti-racist rally recalls 100 years of South Asian leadership against white supremacy in the Fraser Valley: By Ivan Drury
City launches more temporary housing on the eve of Quality Inn mass evictions: By Lama Mugabo and Maria Wallstam
Ross House tenants fight evictions, rent increases: By Jean Swanson and Maria Wallstam
New Year, Same Fight – Resisting cops as mental health workers in Victoria: By Ashley Mollison
BC’s broken Residential Tenancy system adds insult to demoviction in Burnaby: By Ivan Drury
Go ahead displace me, you’re going to have to kill me to get me to stop fighting: By Daniel Bernard Phillip Isadore (Driftpile Cree)
Build community power – support The Volcano newspaper: By the Editors
Top 10 of 2016 – This year’s 3 most-read Volcano articles and 7 you might have missed: By the Editors
Being the thinking point between experience and action – Social movement journalism in 2016, a Volcano year in review: By Ivan Drury
Not the solution we need – A first glance at the federal government’s legal response during the opioid crisis: By Sarah Sheridan
Cancelling the promised Maple Ridge shelter is part of a broader anti-poor reaction: By Ivan Drury
Organized destruction – CMHC data reveals the City of Burnaby is hemorrhaging apartments: By Rick McGowan
Kwantlen Nation leads the fight against Kinder Morgan pipeline transgression of territorial and political sovereignty: By the Editors

2 Comments

  1. December 4 – December 10, 2016 Volcano Newsletter
    ― December 9, 2016 - 1:32 pm  Reply

    […] The Housing Crisis and Anti-Asian Racism […]

  2. Being the thinking point between experience and action – Social movement journalism in 2016, a Volcano year in review: Ivan Drury
    ― December 21, 2016 - 8:12 am  Reply

    […] and published an entire newsletter dedicated to the speeches of community activists dissecting the racist, settler, imperialist discourse. We exposed the misnomers that the Trudeau government was creating […]

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

   
Support our work by making a donation.
 
   
Subscription options
 
 

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Search

Authors

Browse by author

Categories

Archives

Letters to the Editor

1
Sad Siren Song: By Tracey Morrison

― February 12, 2017

Community Spotlight: Jean Swanson

For our issue on the BC Liberal legacy, Volcano editors turned to our Community Spotlight on a legacy of our own to highlight her over 40 years of anti-poverty work. Jean Swanson is an editor with The Volcano alongside her work with the Carnegie Community Action Project. She previously worked with the Downtown Eastside Residents’ Association (DERA) and is the author of a book titled Poorbashing: The Politics of Exclusion.

You’ve been active in anti-poverty work for a long time. What has been the biggest realization that you have had with regards to poverty in this province? Has your understanding or approach to government changed over time and through experience?

My approach to government has definitely changed. Back in 1979, I actually ran as an NDP MLA candidate because I thought being involved in electoral politics was a way of implementing the things you’ve been fighting for in the community. I ran with COPE for city council too, along with my co-workers Bruce Eriksen and Libby Davies, who were elected. In those days it seemed possible to get city council to do some good things for the Downtown Eastside if we worked hard at it: fund the Carnegie Centre, pass a Standards of Maintenance bylaw, put sprinklers in the hotels.

In the early 90s, after the NDP cut welfare and brought in a whole poorbashing framework to justify it, I couldn’t bring myself to vote at all, let alone run for office.

Read more about Jean Swanson's commitment to anti-poverty organizing here.

The Volcano is published on traditional, ancestral, and unceded Coast Salish Territories.

Alliance Against Displacement: The Volcano is affiliated with the Alliance Against Displacement, a pan-regional anti-displacement network of local communities, organizations, and activists fighting displacement on the ground.

  • Housing struggles
  • Gentrification & displacement
  • Racism & Migrant Justice
  • Indigenous & Colonialism
  • Police & Criminalization
  • Income inequality
  • Sex workers
  • Social Movement strategies
  • Climate & Ecology
  • DTES organizations
  • Women & Gender
  • International struggles
  • Health & Harm reduction
  • Culture, art & poetry
  • City & community planning
Copyright © The Volcano